9 Aug Other Losses caused an international scandal when first published in by revealing that Allied Supreme Commander Dwight Eisenhower’s. 17 Apr much controversy among scholars and other interested readers. And yet, James Bacque keeps ferreting out more information that makes his. 30 Aug Other Losses: An Investigation into the Mass Deaths of German Prisoners of War after World War Two by James Bacque Macdonald, pp.
|Published (Last):||1 July 2014|
|PDF File Size:||12.20 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||10.60 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
The book claims that the U. Bacque’s “missing million” were old men and young boys in the Volkssturm People’s Militia released without formal discharge and transfers of POWs to other allies control areas.
Other Losses – Wikipedia
Bohme noted that, of the 5 million prisoners in Losses hands, the European Theater of Operations provost marshall recorded a total of 15, prisoner deaths. Bacque states that he has received letters and phone calls from about 2, Germans who survived the camps, expressing gratitude that other losses james bacque truth about other losses james bacque experience has finally been published.
And they happened at the end of a war we fought for decency and freedom, and they are not excusable. As a consequence of those and other shortcomings, the book “makes charges that are demonstrably absurd. These soldiers were instead handed over to the Soviet Union. The book claims that there was a “method of genocide” in the banning of Red Cross inspectors, the returning of food aid, the policy regarding shelter building, and soldier ration policy. Several historians rebutting Bacque have argued that the missing POWs simply went home, that Red Cross food aid was sent to displaced civilians and that Other losses james bacque POWs were fed the same rations that the U.
Zone and was eventually othee that 3. Other Losses claims that the U. Facts against Falsehood refuted Bacque’s wily misinterpretations of statistics and oral history evidence in detail.
Lauben as the source for the claim that the “other losses” weekly report column covered up deaths.
Other Losses concludes that the food crisis in Europe was contrived by Allied forces by the use of restrictive food import policy, including restrictions on Red Other losses james bacque food deliveries, and other means. Bischoff said that while “most scholarly reviewers of Bacque’s book have pointed out that Bacque fails to establish the proper historical context”, “worse, the historical records that Bacque did use are amateurishly misrepresented other losses james bacque often misleading or wrong.
In the text it is claimed that at leastdied in the US and French camps that is, at least ten times the number killed in combat in North-West Europe from June to April of which somewhere betweenanddied in French captivity.
Other losses james bacque others will do so. It has long been known that German prisoners of war suffered terribly at the end of World War II, that they died by the thousands after hostilities ceased in the European theater, and that many were required to work as forced laborers for the victors. Bacque has simply distorted the context beyond all recognition. Villa also states that Bacque’s assertion that the British rejected designations ja,es not comply with the GC requirements are entirely unfounded and ignore that the British themselves requested that they be permitted to use such designations, with that request being granted by the CCS and used in surrenders to British troops.
oosses Army employed a number of methods to reduce the number of prisoners officially on hand. Other Losses charges that hundreds of thousands of German prisoners that had fled the Eastern front were designated as ” Disarmed Enemy Forces ” in order to avoid recognition under the Third Geneva Conventionfor the purpose of carrying out their other losses james bacque through disease or slow starvation. The total death rates for United States-held prisoners is also far lower than those held by most countries throughout the war.
Numerous reviews of the book written by the top talent in lisses military history profession such as John Keegan and Russel Weigley were persuaded by the findings of the book. Food in occupied Germany. Other Losses states that Eisenhower sought to sidestep the requirements of the Geneva Convention through the designation of these prisoners lossse Disarmed Enemy Forces DEFspecifically stating that “in Bcaque, as Germany other losses james bacque being cracked No agencies were allowed to visit the camps or provide any assistance to the prisoners,  including delegates from ICRC International Committee of the Red Crosswhich was a violation of the Geneva Convention.
He said “Our other losses james bacque for the proper use of relief supplies placed in our care gacque incompatible with a restriction to the fulfillment of orders which render us powerless to furnish relief which we ourselves judge necessary.
For the most part, Bacque’s book is not very original at all. Time Magazine Monday, Oct. Army was providing to the civilian population. The introduction to the book publishing many of the New Orleans panel papers also noted that Bacque other losses james bacque the greatest source of for the “other losses” column, an August Report of the Military Governor that states “An additional group ofare lists as ‘other losses’consisting largely of members of the Volkssturm [People’s Militia] released without a formal charge.
Other losses james bacque short, Eisenhower faced shortages even before he learned that there were at least 17 million more people to feed in Germany than he had expected not to mention all of the other countries in war ravaged Europe, the Philippines, Okinawa and Japan.
Army warehouses had Bacque I reminded him that my memory has deteriorated badly during the 40 odd years since Log In Register for Online Access. Regarding the impossibility of a conspiracy on the scale purported by Bacque, Villa states that “[i]n truth, had Eisenhower committed the other losses james bacque Bacque alleges, someone surely would have gossiped, ratted, leaked, or even just hinted.
Brech discussed his experiences in detail, in which he witnessed the poor conditions other losses james bacque the camp, the large number of deaths, and the systematic starving of the prisoners.
Other Losses explains jammes Eisenhower’s staff must have been implicated, charging “[t]he squalor of the camps came from the moral squalor polluting the higher levels of the army.
Once Bacque’s endnotes are checked, frequent misreadings of documents are easily discernible. Konrad Adenauer later Chancellor of Germany stating that “The German prisoners have been penned up for weeks without any protection from the weather, without drinking water, without medical care. other losses james bacque
All Europe went on rations for the next three years, including Britainuntil the food crisis was over.